[ad_1]
A Hong Kong court has dismissed an attempt to challenge the government’s revision of the Covid-19 law, a move that authorized the health ministry to cancel nearly 20,000 vaccination certificates a day after the same court ruled that he was not entitled to do so.
Justice Russell Coleman of the High Court on Thursday agreed to allow serial killer Kwok Cheuk-kin to apply for a judicial review of the amendment. Kwok argued that there is no “appeal process” for those who have had their vaccination certificates revoked under the Vaccination Pass (Vaccine Pass) Act.
The law was amended last week to authorize Health Secretary Lo Chung-mau to declare that jab injection certificates issued by some doctors are invalid.
The move came a week after Coleman ruled against Kwok in his first review of the case. The judge said at the time that the government did not have the authority to revoke the certificates issued by the seven doctors who allegedly issued them without properly handling medical information.
In his decision written Thursday on Kwok’s second request, Coleman said the government has decided not to appeal its previous decision, which he took as a concession.
“[T]The approval of the cap can be seen as an example of the rule of law at work in Hong Kong,” he wrote.
The judge cited comments that said the constitutional amendment move would “close the loophole,” which he said was “absolutely inaccurate.” The word “loophole” may mean that the council was supposed to give the health minister the power to revoke the jab vaccine certificates but did not do so, he said. But in its previous ruling, it ruled differently that Congress did not intend to give those powers to the president.
The amendments came about because of “unforeseen circumstances,” Coleman wrote, adding that the government “just changed its mind.” The change in circumstances will also include the authorities’ “willingness” to punish those who can be proven to be abusing the medical supply certification system, he said.
“[T]even the amendment of Cap 599L is not necessary to achieve that, as shown by the criminal charges filed and the alleged acts which may be professional,” the judgment said.
Rejecting Kwok’s attempt to challenge the amendment, Coleman said the candidate had misunderstood the revised rules if he said that the affected certificate holders could not restore the requirements for the Kano Kano.
Although there is no provision in the reform law for the public to “appeal” or “revoke” the cancellation of a certification, there are steps they can take to prevent getting the Covid-19 jab , including the use of an issued transfer certificate. by the health chief.
“There is no absolute barrier against those who are affected [medical exemption certificate] The owners from returning the position from the requirements of the Kano Kano,” wrote the judge.
Kwok, dubbed the “king of legal reviews,” also quoted a Chinese media report as saying it was “unlawful or unreasonable” to block access to certain areas based on authority. vaccine. He claims that Coleman’s dismissal was a “substantial increase” on the law and that the Vaccination Pass “has no real or very practical meaning.”
The Vaccines Pass program has a legitimate goal of protecting public health, the judge said, adding that it would help increase vaccination rates and reduce the number of cases of disease and adverse symptoms.
Lee: Legal changes reflect ‘stronger’ law
Chief Executive John Lee described the government’s defeat in a legal review case against claims the city “does not have human rights”. In an interview with TVB that aired last month, Lee said he had to criticize a foreign media outlet, without naming him, after they said Hong Kong authorities were “repressing without speaking.”
“We just sued the government and now it’s gone. Does Hong Kong have no human rights? It’s impossible.” Lee said.
On Tuesday this week, Lee said the government’s decision to change the law – after the law was defeated – was “a very strong example” of the law. He called HKFP’s questioning of constitutional concerns “misguided.”
“The judgment indicates that there is a gap that needs to be filled, so – according to the decision – we will work to fill that gap to ensure that the work we do has a legal basis,” he said. . public health needs to be protected “quickly and effectively,” he said in a weekly news conference.
So far, the police have arrested 39 people – six doctors, seven clinic staff and 26 patients – on false allegations. The army is looking for a doctor. Their crimes include making false devices, attempting to defraud and entering a computer with a fraudulent intent.
Support HKFP | Code of Ethics | Error/typo? | Contact Us | Read | Transparency and Annual Reporting
DEALING WITH COVID-19 IN HONG KONG
HKFP GUIDE
[ad_2]
Source link
